Social Media Decline
Social Media: From Fertile Farms to Wastelands
Social media is in rapid decline. What was once a thriving space for innovation, meaningful discussion, and genuine human connection has become a hollow shell of its former self, plagued by corporate greed, algorithmic manipulation, and censorship. Over the past two decades, we've seen multiple platforms rise and fall, often repeating the same cycle of growth, monetization, exploitation, and ultimate failure. As we stand at the precipice of another major shift in online culture, it’s worth examining how we got here, which platforms have collapsed under their own weight, and what the future holds for social media.
Reddit: Repeating the Digg Downfall
Reddit was once heralded as the “front page of the internet,” a user-driven platform with an emphasis on community-based discussion. But in recent years, its corporate leadership has followed the well-worn path of previous failed platforms, enacting changes that prioritize revenue at the expense of users. The recent API changes, which essentially killed third-party apps, alienated a significant portion of the user base. Now, rumors of Reddit moving toward a paywall model further signal its inevitable downfall. This trajectory mirrors the infamous collapse of Digg, which similarly alienated its core user base by pushing monetization schemes and algorithm-driven content while ignoring community feedback. As history has shown, platforms that attempt to monetize in ways that alienate their core users rarely recover, and Reddit seems doomed to repeat Digg’s mistakes.
Facebook: From Innovation to Irrelevance
Facebook, once an unstoppable force in social networking, has deteriorated into a bloated and buggy experience. It has become a place where engagement is artificially inflated by outrage algorithms and low-quality content, pushing users away. Many people have chosen to abandon their accounts entirely, opting for a life without the invasive data mining and constant attempts to manipulate their attention. Meta’s pivot to the metaverse has largely been a disaster, further illustrating the company’s detachment from what users actually want.
Twitter: The Musk Meltdown
Elon Musk’s acquisition of Twitter has been nothing short of chaotic. While the platform was already struggling before he took over, his leadership has accelerated its decline. His insistence on pushing features like paid verification has made Twitter less credible, while content moderation changes have created a more chaotic and toxic environment. Many power users and brands have left, and alternative platforms have struggled to pick up the slack, leaving a vacuum where real-time social discourse once thrived.
TikTok: The Popular Platform Under Siege
TikTok has managed to captivate younger audiences with its short-form video format, but its dominance is under threat due to government scrutiny. Accusations of data collection and foreign influence have led to serious discussions about banning the platform in multiple countries, including the U.S. While TikTok has remained resilient, its future is uncertain, and if it were to disappear, it’s unclear whether any existing platform could replace its level of engagement.
Hacker News: A Closed Tech Bro System
Hacker News, which presents itself as a discussion forum for tech enthusiasts, has become an insular community where any dissent from the prevailing tech industry narratives is shunned. The platform operates with many unwritten rules and shadowbans users regularly, often without any explanation. Any viewpoint that threatens the financial or ideological interests of its dominant user base—primarily Silicon Valley insiders—is quietly suppressed. This is emblematic of a broader trend across social media: platforms implementing hidden moderation policies that punish users without transparency. Users often find their accounts banned or their content restricted with no clear reason, no appeals process, and no way to regain their audience.
Google: Repeated Social Media Failures and Unaccountable Bans
Google has a long history of failed social media ventures, including Google+, Orkut, and Wave, all of which failed due to mismanagement and lack of user adoption. Beyond its inability to create a successful platform, Google has also developed a reputation for quietly banning users across its services with no explanation. Many users have found their Google accounts—including emails, YouTube channels, and business assets—suddenly disabled with no clear reason and no way to recover them. This mirrors a disturbing trend where social media companies implement arbitrary and opaque moderation policies, leaving users powerless against automated bans and shadowy rule enforcement.
Ars Technica: From Professional Journalism to Swill
Ars Technica was once regarded as a high-quality source of technology journalism, known for in-depth reporting, expert analysis, and insightful discussions. However, in recent years, the site has seen a noticeable decline in quality. Many articles now seem hastily written, riddled with inaccuracies, and often filled with sensationalist takes that resemble clickbait more than professional journalism. Additionally, the site appears to accept content from contributors with questionable expertise, further diluting its credibility. The shift toward lower-quality content and spam-like articles has eroded trust in the platform, driving away long-time readers who once relied on Ars Technica for thoughtful and accurate reporting.
The Death of Independent and Unique Content
Platforms like Slashdot, once revered for their niche communities and insightful commentary, have become unrecognizable. Instead of curating unique stories, these platforms have become rehashes of whatever is already trending elsewhere. The shift away from deep engagement towards shallow, click-driven content has reduced social media to a repetitive cycle of viral trends, ensuring that no space remains for meaningful discussion.
The Death of Comment Sections
Another disturbing trend in the collapse of online discourse is the removal of comment sections from many previously interactive websites. Sites that once encouraged discussion and debate have increasingly opted to shut down user engagement entirely. One example is TorrentFreak, which removed its comment section, effectively silencing discussion on its articles. Other sites, including major news outlets like NPR and Reuters, have also removed comments under the justification of "reducing moderation costs" or "improving the user experience." However, the real impact has been a significant reduction in community engagement, pushing discussions to be fragmented across external platforms where they are harder to follow and often subject to even stricter moderation. This shift signals a broader move toward controlled narratives where user voices are unwelcome and discussions that challenge prevailing viewpoints are quietly erased.
Where Is Social Media Headed?
The downward trajectory of social media can only go so far before new systems emerge to replace the old ones. However, the paths this downfall can take are concerning:
- Paywalls and Subscription Models - As advertising revenue becomes less viable, more platforms will likely introduce paywalls, further fragmenting online spaces and locking quality content behind a price barrier.
- Algorithmic Dominance - The continued reliance on AI-driven feeds ensures that platforms prioritize engagement over accuracy, worsening misinformation, outrage cycles, and the decline of meaningful discussion.
- Government Regulation and Censorship - With increasing pressure from governments, social media platforms are forced to comply with laws that stifle free expression. This will likely result in either excessive censorship or platforms choosing to operate in only the most legally favorable regions.
- The Fragmentation of Online Communities - As major platforms lose their grip, users will scatter to smaller, decentralized alternatives. This could lead to a resurgence of niche forums and independent websites, but it may also make finding and engaging with content more difficult.
- AI-Generated Spam and Deepfakes - With generative AI becoming more sophisticated, we’re already seeing an influx of low-quality, AI-generated content. The problem will only get worse, making it harder to distinguish between real people and automated content farms.
Conclusion
Social media as we once knew it is dying, and its decline is accelerating. The relentless pursuit of profit has transformed once-beloved platforms into barely functioning ad-driven machines, and the user experience has suffered as a result. The future of social media is uncertain, but it’s clear that the golden age of online communities has come to an end. Whether the next iteration of the internet will be better or worse remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the platforms we once relied on are crumbling under the weight of their own greed and mismanagement.
Toddler Investors
Introduction
The investment landscape is moving at an ever-increasing pace, with investors often making funding decisions in mere minutes. The rise of trend-driven investments, such as artificial intelligence, has led to a system that prioritizes popularity over true innovation. ...
Rethinking PCs: A practical approach
Tags:
tech
The current trajectory of computer hardware development has increasingly diverged from the practical needs of everyday users. Manufacturers continue to push advancements in speed, power efficiency, and display resolutions—yet for most people, these improvements offer diminishing real-world ben...
Peak Mall Theory
Tags:
japan
US mall death, Japan mall life
The decline of shopping malls in the United States is a well-documented phenomenon, while in Japan, malls remain thriving, bustling centers of commerce, entertainment, and community life. This contrast raises an interesting question: why have Japane...
Email is Outdated
Email seems ubiquitous and irreplaceable. Is it though? It was created for a useful purpose, and worked effectively
for a number of years, but I would argue that it is outdated and needs to be replaced by something better as
soon as possible.
I explore here why I believe email...
Identity System
Over my career in software I've repeatedly had to deal with issues of identity. Another way to refer to identity
is usernames. The most pervasive identity system in use is email, although it is quickly being supplanted by
cell phone number.
Almost every user of the internet ha...
LinkedIn is Buggy
The main social platform I use is LinkedIn. I've been using it for many years. Over my years of using it I've
found it to be very buggy. I began posting the bugs I found as LinkedIn posts. That didn't seem to get much
attention or have any meaningful affect, so I created a Github pro...
My time is worth $x per hour
In the all too recent history I was feeling proud of my day job, and I thought to myself "I can made $x per
hour." A bit more thinking I came to the conclusion "I shouldn't do anything that takes me an hour that I could
pay someone else to do for less than $x per hour." I believed th...
Job Descriptions
I am connected to quite a few recruiters and managers on LinkedIn. As a result of this, I often
see posts about what candidate's resumes should look like, what information they should contain,
how they should approach applying to jobs etc.
Changing the way you apply for roles ...
UMD Data Breach
A bit over 5 years ago I was involved in the events following a serious data breach at the University
of Maryland. I was pulled into the FBI / Secret Service investigation due to my involvement. It may not
be clear, but I did not start the data breach. Criminal elements of unknown so...
Blog
Welcome to my public blog. I haven't blogged publicly in quite a number of years. This is in part due
to the overwhelming amount of random information available about me already, and I am unsure about
adding to the pile.
I have decided that adding information of higher quality...